Mary Janice (Smith) Eyman

Mary Janice (Smith) Eyman died peacefully at Luther Terrace in Altamont on Feb. 10, 2020 with her four loving daughters at her side.

The family held a visitation on Sunday, Feb. 16 at Pagel Funeral Homes in St. Elmo from 4-7 p.m. Funeral services were held on Monday, Feb. 17 at Luther Terrace Chapel in Altamont with preservice visitation at 1 p.m. and service at 2 p.m. A graveside service followed at Maplewood Cemetery in St. Elmo. Condolences may be expressed at

Mary was born Jan. 7, 1932, the second child of Wallace and Alta (Causey) Smith in rural Pittsburgh, Seminary township. Mary attended Shiloh Grade School in Pittsburgh with her future husband, Elvin Byrl Eyman, and Vandalia High School. She played the piano; loved attending church; and playing with her pet lambs, goat, and kittens. Mary was baptized at age 18 in Hurricane Creek, Pittsburgh. Elvin, her then intended husband, was present at that important event. Elvin and Mary were married at her home church, The Pittsburg Free Methodist Church, on Oct. 7, 1951.

Mary completed a B.S. in Elementary Education at Greenville College in Greenville. She later completed a Master of Science in Education at Eastern Illinois University in Charleston, while working full-time and as a mother to four children. Mary taught elementary grades in the Loudon School District and the St. Elmo School District for 32-and-a-half years. She was always fondly remembered by her students and often taught multiple generations of the same families.

Mary was a faithful member of St. Elmo Church of God and later New Horizon Church for many years. She served on the Board of Missions for the First Church of God and stayed committed to sharing her faith with others throughout her life.

Mary was a talented seamstress, quilter, candy-maker, and cook. Many Sundays were enjoyed sitting around the dinner table with a feast she had prepared for immediate and extended family to enjoy. Mary also operated a small business in St. Elmo with a treasured friend and partner to supply area teachers with all the tools needed to practice their craft.

She was proceeded in death by her parents; her brother, LaVerle Smith; and her loving husband of 55 years. Mary is survived by daughters JoSue (Larry) Stine of St. Elmo, Nancy (Dan) Haslett of St. Elmo, Paula Eyman of Jasper, Ind., and Nola (Steve) Wood of Simpsonville, S.C. Grandma Mary was adored by her 13 grandchildren, 25 great-grandchildren, and four great-great-grandchildren.

Leave a Comment